Hello everybody
I'm a graduate student and my unfortunate task is to try to make sense of
Heidegger's Hegel-interpretation. I'm only at the very beginning
of my work and at the moment studying Heidegger's
reading of Hegel's PhG. The two main texts are 'Hegel's Ph{nomenologie
des Geistes' and 'Hegel's Begriff der Erfarhrung' (don't have the
GA-numbers zuhanden). I would be very greatful if anybody could give me
hints on secondary literature. I know that David Gandolpho and Ed Lawry
debated on this in Southwestern Phil Rev (Jan and Jul 1994). Lawry
referred to Robert R. Williams' article on Hegel and His Critics. (Ed. by
William Desmond, SUNY 1989). I myself find Williams' article
thoroughly unsymphatetic to Heidegger and unhelpful
for trying to find out what exactly Heidegger is doing in his Hegel-lectures.
Dennis Schmidt's The Ubiquity of the Finite (SUNY 1988) is in my
knowledge the only work where proper effort is made in really reading
Heidegger's 'Hegel's Begriff der Erfahrung'. David Kolb has also written
balanced accounts on Hegel and Heidegger but not much (in my knowledge)
on Heidegger's explicit work on Hegel. Does anybody know of good recent
literature on Heidegger's PhG-reading? Anglo or german. I would very much
appreciate any help! (I'm quite new on this list so I dont know if you have
had some debate on the Hegel-Heidegger-relation.)
(desperately) yours: Heikki Ikaeheimo
--- from list heidegger@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---