In a message dated 05/11/2004 18:06:11 GMT Standard Time,
michael@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx writes:
Jud 's thinking:
And since
you have (without any external bidding) brought a former list member, Andrea
Weaver, into this, whom we both have met outside the list, in the dreaded
flesh, as it were, you should hear what she has said about you! But I won't
say. Too indiscreet.
Jud:
Nothing to do with her at all AAMOF. Someone [from this list] posted me
two pics of you which he found somewhere on
the net - It was THEIR subject heading that read: *Voila! The Bald
Pain-in-the Arse Dwarf.*
Michael:
It is not ad hom to say that your brand of philosophy is dwarfish and bereft
compared to that of which you 'criticise' and reject with unabated venom at
every opportunity (and even without any such).
Jud:
What's this - a breakthrough? You have suddenly realised that there are
other brands of philosophy
in addition to your own metaphysical melaena? What has happened to your
arrogant assertion that
to turn away from philosophy is to turn away from Heidycrap? That Heidycrap
in fact IS PHILOSOPHY.
I can hear the laughter rolling down the corridors of shame even as I type
these words.
Michael:
I have never ever spoken of you as a man (I do not know you qua-man,
qua-person), only as a peddler of
your writings, only in terms of your speech and the kind of speech your
speech bespeaks. I have never ever (from the outset in 2000)hidden the
utmost contempt I have for your awful version of philosophising, although I
have made repeated efforts to go along with (critically, reasonably) your
mode of thinking in order to display cracks in your armour [sic]; during
such interchanges, I have never ever referred to your physical
characteristics or your possibly uncharming behaviours, but you, when the
devil gets you, and it does so very very often, nearly always find as many
ways as you can, space-time considerations pending, of defiling other people
you have never met with the most disgusting descriptions you can find in
your immense vocabulary and seemingly unlimited feverish imagination.
Jud:
To attack the body of what I say in my anti-Heideggerian philosophy polemic
- I do not mind.
What I do constitute as a personal attack is attack on my integrity as a
person - in other words
I constitute that as being similar to a physical attack.
Michael:
You are a most driven man it seems (and that needn't be anything but
brilliant, but I think it depends upon what drives you, love or hate,
e.g.?).
Jud:
I have never made any secret of the fact that I am driven by a hatred for
Heidegger and all that he stands for. I have dedicated the rest of my
philosophical life to oppose his lies and evil stupidities, and will continue to do so
as long as I have breath in my body.
That however is only a small part of my intellectual, philosophical,
business and social life. As a speed typist I need spend no more than a maximum two
hours a day on the computer.
As for you - you are consumed and driven by your weird love for the
Freiburgian freak, and are even engaged in writing an opera about him - who will play
Heidegger's part the tiny Ronnie Corbett? What's it going to be called:
*The Metaphysical Mengele of Marburgian? That will go down a treat in New York
won't it?
MIchael:
You will not but I so do wish you would find another place to troll:
I have learnt all I need to learn from you, which is a lot. Since you will
not, I have yet again to make another yet again resolution never to read or
respond to another post by you. So op!
Michael [from a post to Rene]
ps: for Jud, since you'll be reading this -- I employed the word "fuck"
recently not in a gratuitous swearing insulting exclamatory sense but in its
perfectly correct sense of 'to have sexual intercourse' (as almost anyone
could see from the context).
Jud:
I suppose you speak like that in whatever ratholes you frequent socially do
you?
Do you speak like that to your rabbi? Do you speak like that to your
family?
In front of ladies too no doubt? No? Then why do you insult what ladies and
people of culture
there may be on this list with your schoolboy filth? Respect for the other
sex? You don't know the meaning of the word.
Poo? I hope you mean it this time, but if I know you of old, you will simply
resort to your usual sly, trollish. Heideggerian-style hate campaign via an
insouciant proxy like you have taken to doing with Rene in the last couple of
posts. You haven't even got the guts to perform your poisoned dwarf routine
like a man - and address me personally instead of hiding behind the
skirts/trousers of a third party. You forget - you've got loadsa *form* - your
behaviour is predictable.
--- StripMime Warning -- MIME attachments removed ---
This message may have contained attachments which were removed.
Sorry, we do not allow attachments on this list.
--- StripMime Report -- processed MIME parts ---
multipart/alternative
text/plain (text body -- kept)
text/html
---
--- from list heidegger@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ---